In order to start the game, the player will have to interact with the Yellow Tattletail. The lights will go out, and Mama Tattletail will begin her pursuit. After a certain amount of time, the lights turn back on, Mama disappears and the player needs to find the Yellow Tattletail. This happens 3 times, and each round increases the timer by 30 seconds.
Yellow Tattletail first hides under the Christmas tree, and then in the Protagonist's wardrobe, and finally in the basement, where Mama Tattletail was on Night 3.
- This minigame is advantageous to getting a secret achievement involving Mom's door, since Mama will follow the player until the hide and seek minigame is over.